We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
  • Analytics
    AnalyticsShow More
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about joining public web signals with internal business metrics so BI teams can inter
    Alternative Data in BI: Bringing Public Web Data Into Your Dashboards
    23 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about automating the collection, preparation, and delivery of marketing data across p
    From Data to Dashboards: 5 Marketing Reporting Automation Software Picks
    12 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts passive follower totals with a behavioral path from attention and trust to cli
    Creator Analytics Beyond Follower Count: Seven Metrics That Measure Audience Behavior
    11 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article connects AI and marketing analytics with managerial judgment grounded in consumer behavi
    How an Online MBA in Marketing Connects AI and Data Analytics
    11 Min Read
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers -- AI-generated illustration
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers
    7 Min Read
  • Big Data
  • BI
  • Exclusive
  • IT
  • Marketing
  • Software
Search
© 2008-25 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: The Perils of Marketing Attribution
Share
Notification
Font ResizerAa
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
SmartData Collective > Business Intelligence > CRM > The Perils of Marketing Attribution
AnalyticsCRMSocial Media AnalyticsWeb Analytics

The Perils of Marketing Attribution

BillFranks
BillFranks
9 Min Read
The Perils of Marketing Attribution
Illustration generated with FLUX.2 [klein 4B] via Cloudflare Workers AI.
SHARE

Editor’s note (4/22/2015): We’re proud to announce that Bill Franks will be sharing his expertise at The Social Shake-Up 2015 in June. Register here!

Contents
  • Common Attribution Options
  • The Lack of Objective Assessment Criteria
  • A Startling Finding
  • What To Do?

One of the hottest topics in analytics today is marketing attribution. Attribution, for those unfamiliar, is the process of assigning credit to various marketing efforts when a sale is generated. In the modern world, this is no easy task. There are myriad ways to touch a customer today and the goal of attribution is to tease out the impact that each touch had in convincing you to make a purchase.

Was it the email you were sent? Or the Google link you clicked? Or the banner ad you clicked when visiting a different site? Or the ad you saw with your video on YouTube? Or one of many other potential touch points? Or is it a mix? It is quite common today for a customer to have been exposed to multiple influences in the lead up to a purchase. How do you attribute the relat

The question is not simply academic because it has real world consequences. Budgets are set based on performance. So, the person in charge of Google advertising has a huge motivation to ensure that they get all the credit they deserve. Also, accurate attribution will allow resources to be properly focused on the approaches that truly work best. If only it were as easy to attribute credit accurately as it is to make the case for doing it!

More Read

The Center of Analytics Success Takes on Communication Skills
The Center of Analytics Success Takes on Communication Skills
My Life as a Bee with SAS – Observe, Learn and Share
The Quantified Self, Part I: Will it Lead to Better Data Management?
Analyzing Enterprise Text? Don’t Use Sentiment Out of Context
Has Your Data Quality Been Naughty or Nice?

Common Attribution Options

The most common attribution methods, such as the “last touch” method, are very simple. If the last thing I do before a purchase is to click a banner ad, for example, then the banner ad gets 100% of the credit while any prior interactions get nothing. Sorry, email team, search team, and everyone else! While this method is simple to implement, it doesn’t sit well with analytical minds. As a result, organizations have tried all sorts of different methods. These include:

  • A uniform credit to all touch points involved.
  • Set weightings. Perhaps the final touch point gets 3 credits, the first gets 2 credits, and everything in between gets one credit.
  • Exponential weightings, with a set decay rate. For example, the final touch point is given one unit of credit, the prior touch point gets 1/2 credit, the one before that gets 1/4, and so on.
  • Weights customized by the perceived power of a given touch point. If email is considered more motivational than a banner ad, email starts with more credit than a banner ad within any of the prior methods.
  • Weights determined by the parameters from a model that predicts conversion as a function of the touch points involved.

I could go on. But, by now you should get the point that there are many attribution options to choose from. Don’t forget any given vendor’s “secret sauce” option that purports to be superior and that you can only gain access to by paying a large sum of money!

The Lack of Objective Assessment Criteria

One day, when I was involved in a heated discussion about what the “best” attribution methodology is, something hit me like a ton of bricks. Namely, there is not a quantifiable, objective benchmark against which to measure attribution algorithms to determine which is best.

When building a response model, for example, the measure of success is the ability to correctly identify responses. The better a model can do this, the better it is, and there is no subjectivity involved. If my model does a better job of finding responders than yours, then we would agree that mine is objectively better with no argument. The majority of common analytic techniques applied in a business setting fall into this category.

There are other types of analysis, such as cluster analysis, that don’t have a “correct” answer to compare against and therefore involve subjectivity. Attribution falls into this more murky space. We don’t know the actual and true influence of our various touch points and so have no way to validate if one method is “better” than another. We can certainly identify the extent to which the results of different attribution methods yield different results, but then we’re left to argue subjectively one against the other.

Naturally, you can expect the email team to be convinced that the method yielding the most credit for email is the way to go. Other teams will be similarly biased and there is no objective way to settle the argument. So, often the method that is selected is the direct result of the group that has the most political clout in an organization. What a mess!

A Startling Finding

Suresh Pillai, Head of Customer Analytics & Insights for Europe at eBay, and I both spoke at an event in London recently. He talked about the journey that his team had undertaken to find the right attribution approach. He showed a wide range of attribution options and then demonstrated that, in his company’s case, all of them yielded substantially the same results in aggregate. While the exact percentage of credit to a touch point might vary by a few percentage points, the credit was consistently sized compared to others. In other words, touch point 1 always got about twice the aggregate credit of touch point 2 regardless of how simple or fancy the attribution methodology.

Next, Suresh showed the result that shocked me. He added a comparison bar for a purely random attribution method. Shockingly, the pattern of credit in aggregate for the random model also fell right in line with the others. In other words, you could randomly assign credit and still get substantially the same aggregate answer as with any other option even though the credit for individual cases would vary! This is another case of Occam’s Razor at work!

What To Do?

My big takeaway is this: Spend less energy battling over attribution formulas. If one formula is politically more acceptable to your organization than others, just go with it. You’ll be getting substantially the same results no matter what you choose.

Naturally, you might question whether or not eBay’s findings would apply to your specific situation. If so, run the simple test that eBay did. Namely, compare the aggregate results of various options and also compare those results to a random allocation. If they are all virtually the same, make a choice that people are comfortable with and move on to other problems.

If you do find that some methods yield substantially different results from a random allocation, you should expect a battle. With no objective way to know which solution is truly best, the winning approach will be that which satisfies the most stakeholders’ personal interests while offending the fewest.

In the end, your organization must agree on an attribution methodology. However, with all the opportunities for analytics to transform your business decision, don’t get distracted with attribution methodology arguments that will have little real impact on your business. Stay focused on things that will truly matter.

Share This Article
Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn
Share
ByBillFranks
Follow:
Bill Franks is Chief Analytics Officer for The International Institute For Analytics (IIA). Franks is also the author of Taming The Big Data Tidal Wave and The Analytics Revolution. His work has spanned clients in a variety of industries for companies ranging in size from Fortune 100 companies to small non-profit organizations. You can learn more at http://www.bill-franks.com.

Follow us on Facebook

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: The article connects downstream report failures, data-quality gaps, and conflicting metric definitio
Signs Your Data Architecture Needs an Outside Review
Big Data Exclusive
Data-Driven Pultrusion: Best GFRP Rebar Machines & ROI
Data-Driven Pultrusion: Best GFRP Rebar Machines & ROI
Big Data Exclusive
Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts tools for gathering fresh interviews with tools for analyzing existing qualita
10 AI Market Research Tools That Turn Qualitative Data into Insights
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Exclusive
Flat editorial illustration: The article compares proxy MCP servers by what an AI agent can do through them: manage proxy account
Proxy MCP Servers: 7 Options and What Each Lets an AI Agent Do
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Data Collection

Stay Connected

1.2KFollowersLike
33.7KFollowersFollow
222FollowersPin

You Might also Like

Analytics skills in demand – and analytics pros demanding top salaries
Predictive Analytics

Analytics skills in demand – and analytics pros demanding top salaries

5 Min Read
5 Lessons Social CRM can Learn from CRM
CRMPredictive Analytics

5 Lessons Social CRM can Learn from CRM

8 Min Read
Spark the Flame: The Power Behind Real Time Analytics
Predictive Analytics

Spark the Flame: The Power Behind Real Time Analytics

6 Min Read
The New Way to Segment For a 6x Greater Return
AnalyticsBest PracticesData MiningMarketingPredictive Analytics

The New Way to Segment For a 6x Greater Return

5 Min Read

SmartData Collective is one of the largest & trusted community covering technical content about Big Data, BI, Cloud, Analytics, Artificial Intelligence, IoT & more.

Artificial Intelligence for eCommerce: A Closer Look
Artificial Intelligence for eCommerce: A Closer Look
Artificial Intelligence
Chatbots and SEO: How Can Chatbots Improve Your SEO Ranking?
Chatbots and SEO: How Can Chatbots Improve Your SEO Ranking?
Artificial Intelligence Chatbots Exclusive

Quick Link

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-26 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?