We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
  • Analytics
    AnalyticsShow More
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about joining public web signals with internal business metrics so BI teams can inter
    Alternative Data in BI: Bringing Public Web Data Into Your Dashboards
    23 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about automating the collection, preparation, and delivery of marketing data across p
    From Data to Dashboards: 5 Marketing Reporting Automation Software Picks
    12 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts passive follower totals with a behavioral path from attention and trust to cli
    Creator Analytics Beyond Follower Count: Seven Metrics That Measure Audience Behavior
    11 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article connects AI and marketing analytics with managerial judgment grounded in consumer behavi
    How an Online MBA in Marketing Connects AI and Data Analytics
    11 Min Read
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers -- AI-generated illustration
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers
    7 Min Read
  • Big Data
  • BI
  • Exclusive
  • IT
  • Marketing
  • Software
Search
© 2008-25 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Wikipedia or Potemkinpedia?
Share
Notification
Font ResizerAa
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
SmartData Collective > Uncategorized > Wikipedia or Potemkinpedia?
Uncategorized

Wikipedia or Potemkinpedia?

Daniel Tunkelang
Daniel Tunkelang
4 Min Read
Wikipedia or Potemkinpedia?
Illustration generated with Qwen Image.
SHARE

Today’s New York Times features an essay by Noam Cohen entitled “Wikipedia: Exploring Fact City“, in which Cohen explores the metaphor of Wikipedia as an information metropolis, repete with dead-end streets and industrial districts. It’s a nice read, even if Cohen gets a bit carried away with his artistic license.

But Nick Carr reacts strongly to the notion that Wikipedia offers “sidewalk-like transparency and collective responsibility”. In his post, entitled “Potemkinpedia“, Carr argues:

Wikipedia has imposed editorial controls on those articles, restricting who can edit them. Wikipedia has, to extend Cohen’s metaphor, erected a whole lot of police barricades, cordoning off large areas of the site and requiring would-be editors to show their government-issued ID cards before passing through.

Carr is right that that Wikipedia exerts editorial controls, and it’s true that not everyone agrees with Wikipedia’s means of doing so. Still, I feel his tone seems unnecessarily hostile, and he doesn’t point out that the amount of top-down control exerted to maintain Wikipedia is extremely low compared to the value it creates. Indeed, he cites “hundreds” of pages being protected without noting that Wikipedia contains 2,817,176 articles in English alone.

One of Wikipedia’s founding principles is “Assume good faith.” Perhaps I should do that myself, yet I can’t help but wonder if Carr’s relationship with Brittanica predisposes him against Wikipedia. In fairness to Carr, he has pointed out that relationship in some of his articles (like this one). But I actually hunted down a reference on his Wikipedia entry.

More Read

Actuate and OpenText: The Background and Potential Future
Actuate and OpenText: The Background and Potential Future
Don’t Cry, Shopgirl
Nexidia Brings Compliance and Process Management to Interaction Analytics
A Little Too Literal (or, How to Teach Innovation)
The Social Employee Manifesto

Personally, I give Wikipedia high marks for transparency. What other publication exposes the full revision history of its content and provides a public discussion forum for both its content and editorial process? I’ve had my disagreements with that process, but I can’t fault its openness. Indeed, my main criticism of Wikipedia is that it doesn’t require such transparency of authors, but instead allows authors to contribute anonymously.

Perhaps Carr sincerely wants Wikipedia to be more like Brittanica, or at least wants everyone to know that Wikipedia is not 100% unlike Brittanica. And perhaps Cohen offered an oversimplified vision of Wikipedia’s governance that some could see as a utopian vision of anarchy. But I think Carr is being a bit disingenuous. After all, even a metropolis has a mayor.

Share This Article
Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn
Share

Follow us on Facebook

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: The article connects downstream report failures, data-quality gaps, and conflicting metric definitio
Signs Your Data Architecture Needs an Outside Review
Big Data Exclusive
Data-Driven Pultrusion: Best GFRP Rebar Machines & ROI
Data-Driven Pultrusion: Best GFRP Rebar Machines & ROI
Big Data Exclusive
Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts tools for gathering fresh interviews with tools for analyzing existing qualita
10 AI Market Research Tools That Turn Qualitative Data into Insights
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Exclusive
Flat editorial illustration: The article compares proxy MCP servers by what an AI agent can do through them: manage proxy account
Proxy MCP Servers: 7 Options and What Each Lets an AI Agent Do
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Data Collection

Stay Connected

1.2KFollowersLike
33.7KFollowersFollow
222FollowersPin

You Might also Like

Kotter and the Knowing-Doing Gap
Uncategorized

Kotter and the Knowing-Doing Gap

5 Min Read
BI & Analytic Trends for Business Value
Uncategorized

BI & Analytic Trends for Business Value

5 Min Read
The Challenge of Predicting Consumer Response to Innovation
Uncategorized

The Challenge of Predicting Consumer Response to Innovation

6 Min Read
Data Breach Lawsuits Revived: Court Turns in Favor of Consumers
Uncategorized

Data Breach Lawsuits Revived: Court Turns in Favor of Consumers

6 Min Read

SmartData Collective is one of the largest & trusted community covering technical content about Big Data, BI, Cloud, Analytics, Artificial Intelligence, IoT & more.

The Art of Conversation: Enhancing Chatbots with Advanced AI Prompts
The Art of Conversation: Enhancing Chatbots with Advanced AI Prompts
Chatbots
Artificial Intelligence for eCommerce: A Closer Look
Artificial Intelligence for eCommerce: A Closer Look
Artificial Intelligence

Quick Link

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-26 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?