We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
  • Analytics
    AnalyticsShow More
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about joining public web signals with internal business metrics so BI teams can inter
    Alternative Data in BI: Bringing Public Web Data Into Your Dashboards
    23 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about automating the collection, preparation, and delivery of marketing data across p
    From Data to Dashboards: 5 Marketing Reporting Automation Software Picks
    12 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts passive follower totals with a behavioral path from attention and trust to cli
    Creator Analytics Beyond Follower Count: Seven Metrics That Measure Audience Behavior
    11 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article connects AI and marketing analytics with managerial judgment grounded in consumer behavi
    How an Online MBA in Marketing Connects AI and Data Analytics
    11 Min Read
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers -- AI-generated illustration
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers
    7 Min Read
  • Big Data
  • BI
  • Exclusive
  • IT
  • Marketing
  • Software
Search
© 2008-25 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: What’s up with Watson?: Responses to comments in Wall Street Journal
Share
Notification
Font ResizerAa
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
SmartData Collective > Big Data > Data Quality > What’s up with Watson?: Responses to comments in Wall Street Journal
Data QualityMarketing

What’s up with Watson?: Responses to comments in Wall Street Journal

StephenBaker1
StephenBaker1
6 Min Read
What's up with Watson?: Responses to comments in Wall Street Journal
Photo by meycan254 on Pixabay (https://pixabay.com/photos/feedback-customer-opinion-8632282/)
SHARE

The excerpt in the Wall Street Journal sparked some doubts and concerns among readers. I responded to a few, and figured I’d blog them here.

Henry Grimmelsman wrote:
I think the computer will win. He who pays the piper calls the tune, and IBM is bankrolling it. I think the tiny details of how information is relayed to the computer will probably be on terms favorable to the computer. The way I remember the chess competition with Kasparov, Kasparov started dominating the computer early on (in a series of games), and the grandmasters and programmers working on the project got to reprogram it. I didn’t think this was fair. I thought the computer should have to play the whole series with its original program. But IBM sponsored it, and who knows how much Kasparov got for participating, so he was a gracious loser.

The most obvious advantage for the computer is that it only has to worry about taking on humans. Each human is taking on not only the computer, but another human. I’d like to see a contest between one of the human players, the IBM machine, and a machine designed by Google. I can’t help but wonder if a computer that somehow produced answers based on Google queries could beat what IBM programmed.

It’s still a pretty amazing project to build the computer, but I can’t imagine IBM turning it loose without knowing it would win.

More Read

Overcoming Data Management Challenges in Online Channel
Overcoming Data Management Challenges in Online Channel
Leveraging Big data to Boost Sales through Affiliate Marketing
Determining Perception Gap Through Twitter [INFOGRAPHIC]
How the History of Data Gathering Lead to the Age of Big Data
Collecting Analytic Data by Tracking Mobile Visitors: A Guide for Mobile Insights

My response:

Henry, One of the points of contention between IBM and Jeopardy during this process was whether IBM and Watson would have access to top Jeopardy talent for a series of test matches. The IBM team wanted to establish a scientific record of Watson’s performance against humans. And this would provide some backing (and bragging rights) in the event that Watson lost the televised showdown. As in most games, one single match in Jeopardy is unpredicatable. It often boils down to who lands on Daily Doubles. So IBM eventually provided tournament of champion-caliber players to take on Watson in 56 matches through the Fall. Watson won nearly 7 of 10 of these matches. Its greatest vulnerability was in Final Jeopardy, where the clues are usually more complex. One more point about a …quot;sure thing…quot; match for IBM. In order for it to be a sure thing, Watson would have to be such a dominant player that it would render the TV show tedious. Jeopardy was not interested in that.

As far as your point about the computer taking on two humans, instead of vice versa, that’s well taken. Going into the match, both Jennings and Rutter said they would have preferred facing two Watsons rather than one Watson and a supremely talented fellow human. That said, humans below the caliber of Jennings and Rutter did defeat Watson numerous times in recent months. The machine has its vulnerabilities.

I forgot to respond to his point about “details about how the information is relayed to the computer.” There haven’t been any complaints about that. The computer gets the electronic words at the same moment that the humans see the clue. In David Ferrucci’s words to human players: “As soon as it hits your retina, it hits Watson’s chips.” The real arguments centered on the buzzer–a crucial factor in Jeopardy. There was a battle over that, as I describe in the book, and Jeopardy eventually prevailed upon IBM to build “a finger” so that Watson could physically press the button, just like humans. That said, humans in their hurry to press the button occasionally buzz too early–and get penalized a precious quarter second. Watson, responding to the cue to buzz, never gets penalized.

Rich Gibbs wrote:

The “Interactive Graphic” contest is a bit unfair — it makes the game too easy, by using (essentially) a multiple-choice format. Often, a fair chunk of the difficulty in finding an answer, at least for a human contestant, is coming up with a list of eligible answers. Take, for example, a recent clue from the show, in “African Geography” (this is from memory): This West African country’s name appears in the name of an East African country. The answer is “Mali”, which appears in “Somalia.” Not that hard, but if you can’t remember the country names, you can’t even get started.

I agreed:
If Watson could play Jeopardy by selecting multiple choice answers, it would probably never miss one. The challenge for the machine (and for the rest of us) is to find a single response in a universe of information.

Share This Article
Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn
Share

Follow us on Facebook

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: The article compares proxy MCP servers by what an AI agent can do through them: manage proxy account
Proxy MCP Servers: 7 Options and What Each Lets an AI Agent Do
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Data Collection
Flat editorial illustration: The article is about joining public web signals with internal business metrics so BI teams can inter
Alternative Data in BI: Bringing Public Web Data Into Your Dashboards
Big Data Business Intelligence Exclusive Web Analytics
Flat editorial illustration: A SaaS-editorial scene showing product usage, support patterns, and renewal feedback informing a fle
Using Product Usage Analytics and Support Data to Build a B2B Product Roadmap
Business Intelligence Infographic
From Hiring To Payroll: Managing HR Data Across Business Systems -- AI-generated illustration
From Hiring To Payroll: Managing HR Data Across Business Systems
Big Data Business Intelligence Infographic

Stay Connected

1.2KFollowersLike
33.7KFollowersFollow
222FollowersPin

You Might also Like

The Rise of Chatbots (And Why Your Business Needs Them)
MarketingMarketing Automation

The Rise of Chatbots (And Why Your Business Needs Them)

6 Min Read
Are You A Data Whisperer?
Business IntelligenceData QualityDecision Management

Are You A Data Whisperer?

4 Min Read
Mobile Advertising, Clustering Algorithms, and Your Ticket for a Free Ride
AnalyticsBig DataCollaborative DataData MiningData VisualizationExclusiveITLocationMarketingMarketing AutomationMobilityPredictive AnalyticsSocial DataSocial Media AnalyticsSoftwareStatistics

Mobile Advertising, Clustering Algorithms, and Your Ticket for a Free Ride

5 Min Read
Business People Are Dumb On Average(s)
AnalyticsCulture/LeadershipData MiningData QualityDecision Management

Business People Are Dumb On Average(s)

7 Min Read

SmartData Collective is one of the largest & trusted community covering technical content about Big Data, BI, Cloud, Analytics, Artificial Intelligence, IoT & more.

ai chatbot
How AI Website Chatbots Improve Customer Support and Lead Generation
Chatbots Exclusive
Chatbots and SEO: How Can Chatbots Improve Your SEO Ranking?
Chatbots and SEO: How Can Chatbots Improve Your SEO Ranking?
Artificial Intelligence Chatbots Exclusive

Quick Link

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-26 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?