We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
  • Analytics
    AnalyticsShow More
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about joining public web signals with internal business metrics so BI teams can inter
    Alternative Data in BI: Bringing Public Web Data Into Your Dashboards
    23 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article is about automating the collection, preparation, and delivery of marketing data across p
    From Data to Dashboards: 5 Marketing Reporting Automation Software Picks
    12 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts passive follower totals with a behavioral path from attention and trust to cli
    Creator Analytics Beyond Follower Count: Seven Metrics That Measure Audience Behavior
    11 Min Read
    Flat editorial illustration: The article connects AI and marketing analytics with managerial judgment grounded in consumer behavi
    How an Online MBA in Marketing Connects AI and Data Analytics
    11 Min Read
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers -- AI-generated illustration
    What Kind of Problem-Solving Distinguishes Data Analysts From Software Engineers
    7 Min Read
  • Big Data
  • BI
  • Exclusive
  • IT
  • Marketing
  • Software
Search
© 2008-25 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Relying on Data Can Lead to the Wrong Decisions Says CFO.com
Share
Notification
Font ResizerAa
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
SmartData Collective > Big Data > Data Mining > Relying on Data Can Lead to the Wrong Decisions Says CFO.com
AnalyticsData Mining

Relying on Data Can Lead to the Wrong Decisions Says CFO.com

Timo Elliott
Timo Elliott
6 Min Read
Relying on Data Can Lead to the Wrong Decisions Says CFO.com
Photo by qimono on Pixabay (https://pixabay.com/photos/doors-choices-choose-open-decision-1767564/)
SHARE

cfobigdata

I just read a new CFO Magazine article called “That New Big Data Magic”, which contains the following opening paragraphs:

Back in the 1980s, American Airlines (AA) was partnered with British Airways (BA), and AA’s marketing head wanted to know how many of the airline’s gold card members, its most profitable customers, were flying BA rather than AA. Larry Tieman, then a managing director in IT at AA, dove into the massive amounts of data AA had collected on its customers and reported back that, basically, all of AA’s gold card holders were flying BA. The reason seemed obvious: BA’s service simply was better. So AA launched a huge quality-improvement initiative. It upgraded its food service and changed its flight schedules to increase on-time rates. It invested heavily to compete on quality on all fronts.

The results, Tieman recalls, were disastrous.

“None of it mattered,” says Tieman, who between 2000 and 2010 was a senior technology vice president at FedEx. “The quality of food meant nothing. What was sticky was frequent flyer loyalty programs.”

“With Big Data,” Tieman says, “you may be spot-on about a problem, but the solution doesn’t magically appear out of the data.”

The story goes on to say:

“Relying on data alone could lead a company down the path AA took: investing heavily in the wrong things.”

I re-read this several times, and still couldn’t make any sense out of the anecdote:  if frequent flyer loyalty was key, why didn’t the AA fliers stick with AA flights to get the miles? I assume the partnership gave them air miles when they used BA – but presumably they could still get miles on AA, too, so the part about “what was sticky was the frequent flier program” is true but irrelevant and we’re back to the original question, which remains unanswered: why did they fly BA rather than AA?

More Read

Big Data Vs. Traditional Business Intelligence
Big Data Vs. Traditional Business Intelligence
How We Are Heading Towards a Smart Planet with the Internet of Things [INFOGRAPHIC]
Social Media Data and what analysts can do with it
Baking and Computers, a Surprising History of Analytics Pioneers
Is Big Data Under Threat by New Internet Magna Carta?

The anecdote doesn’t back up the conclusion, leading to lots of other questions:

  • Did flying BA give them more miles than BA through the partnership? (sounds like a strange partnership agreement)
  • Were the people flying BA only there was no AA flight available? (marketing head wanted to know when people were flying BA rather than AA, so this would be bad analysis)
  • Were the BA flights free ones, using up the air miles? (even so, what difference would it make to the choice equation?)
  • Did the gold card fliers also have BA cards, and these trumped their AA cards? (I know they used to offer gold cards to people who already had gold cards on other airlines, with the logic that these were good customers, that they wouldn’t change carriers without similar conditions, and the marginal cost of extra people in the priority lineup, etc. is very low)
  • Was the routing different/better (this would explain why food service and schedules didn’t make any difference, but would change the conclusion of what was important)…

In order to find out what was going on, I swapped emails with Larry Tieman, whose quote in the article explains why it’s wrong to “rely on data alone” (you need people):

“what you do with [data] is a people-based activity, a skill base you have to mature. And it doesn’t come quickly.”

It turns out that frequent fliers did indeed get air miles on either airline, and that the “obvious reason” was also the real one: on head-to-head flights, frequent fliers did indeed choose BA because of “the quality of business and first class”. The “quality from the ground up” initiative mentioned cost $1Bn, with little impact: as the last two decades have shown, what most fliers are interested in is lower prices.

So, unlike the article’s assertion,  AA’s problems don’t seem to have had anything to do with “relying on data alone”. Larry’s conclusion over email was rather different:

“My moral, the data can tell you what is wrong but fixing it is another thing all together.”

Overall, it’s maybe a good example of what plagues most business analysis — the data is incomplete and confusing, and isn’t necessarily related to the most important problems people have to deal with! The rest of the article is less controversial, and include a nice summary of what CFOs (and everybody else) should be thinking about in analytics:

“…new technologies are making it more economical to make sense of Big Data which, in fact, has been around for a long, long time. The caveat is that those technologies will not provide those opportunities. That’s still up to the people who make business decisions.”

Finally, as a footnote, I’m with Andy Bitterer that there are four ‘V’s to the information challenge – not just Volume, Velocity, and Variety, but also Validity…

Share This Article
Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn
Share

Follow us on Facebook

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: The article connects downstream report failures, data-quality gaps, and conflicting metric definitio
Signs Your Data Architecture Needs an Outside Review
Big Data Exclusive
Data-Driven Pultrusion: Best GFRP Rebar Machines & ROI
Data-Driven Pultrusion: Best GFRP Rebar Machines & ROI
Big Data Exclusive
Flat editorial illustration: The article contrasts tools for gathering fresh interviews with tools for analyzing existing qualita
10 AI Market Research Tools That Turn Qualitative Data into Insights
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Exclusive
Flat editorial illustration: The article compares proxy MCP servers by what an AI agent can do through them: manage proxy account
Proxy MCP Servers: 7 Options and What Each Lets an AI Agent Do
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Data Collection

Stay Connected

1.2KFollowersLike
33.7KFollowersFollow
222FollowersPin

You Might also Like

Can Big Data and Hadoop Feed the World?
AnalyticsBig DataBusiness IntelligenceData MiningData QualityData VisualizationData WarehousingHadoopITMapReduceOpen SourceSocial DataSoftwareSQLWorkforce Data

Can Big Data and Hadoop Feed the World?

5 Min Read
Brains and Databases: An Obsession with Time Keeping
AnalyticsBusiness IntelligenceData Warehousing

Brains and Databases: An Obsession with Time Keeping

4 Min Read
Internet Topology: Massive and Amazing Graphs
Big DataData VisualizationModelingWeb Analytics

Internet Topology: Massive and Amazing Graphs

1 Min Read
Data Analytics Shows How COVID 19 Impacted Search and User Behavior Online
Analytics

Data Analytics Shows How COVID 19 Impacted Search and User Behavior Online

8 Min Read

SmartData Collective is one of the largest & trusted community covering technical content about Big Data, BI, Cloud, Analytics, Artificial Intelligence, IoT & more.

How To Get An Award Winning Giveaway Bot
How To Get An Award Winning Giveaway Bot
Big Data Chatbots Exclusive
Chatbots and SEO: How Can Chatbots Improve Your SEO Ranking?
Chatbots and SEO: How Can Chatbots Improve Your SEO Ranking?
Artificial Intelligence Chatbots Exclusive

Quick Link

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-26 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?