Search and the social graph

December 14, 2009
62 Views

Google has created a multi-billion-dollar economy based on keywords. We use keywords to find things and advertisers use keywords to find customers. As Michael Arrington points out, this is leading to increasing amounts of low quality, keyword-stuffed content. The end result is a very spammy Internet. (It was depressing to see Tim Armstrong cite Demand Media, a giant domain-name owner and robotic content factory, as a model for the new AOL.)

Some people hope the social web — link sharing via Twitter, Facebook, etc. — will save us. Fred Wilson argues that “social beats search” because it’s harder to game people’s social graph. Cody Brown tweeted:

On Twitter you have to ‘game’ people, not algorithms. Look how many followers @demandmedia has. A lot less then you guys: @arrington @jason

These are both sound points. Lost amid this discussion, however, is that the links people tend to share on social networks – news, blog posts, videos – are in categories Google barely makes money on. (The same point also seems lost on Rupert Murdoch and news organizations who accuse Google of profiting off their misery).

Searches related to news, blog posts, funny videos, etc., are



Google has created a multi-billion-dollar economy based on keywords. We use keywords to find things and advertisers use keywords to find customers. As Michael Arrington points out, this is leading to increasing amounts of low quality, keyword-stuffed content. The end result is a very spammy Internet. (It was depressing to see Tim Armstrong cite Demand Media, a giant domain-name owner and robotic content factory, as a model for the new AOL.)

Some people hope the social web — link sharing via Twitter, Facebook, etc. — will save us. Fred Wilson argues that “social beats search” because it’s harder to game people’s social graph. Cody Brown tweeted:

On Twitter you have to ‘game’ people, not algorithms. Look how many followers @demandmedia has. A lot less then you guys: @arrington @jason

These are both sound points. Lost amid this discussion, however, is that the links people tend to share on social networks – news, blog posts, videos – are in categories Google barely makes money on. (The same point also seems lost on Rupert Murdoch and news organizations who accuse Google of profiting off their misery).

Searches related to news, blog posts, funny videos, etc., are mostly a loss leaders for Google. Google’s real business is selling ads for plane tickets, dvd players, and malpractice lawyers. (I realize this might be depressing to some Internet idealists, but it’s a reality). Online advertising revenue is directly correlated with finding users who have purchasing intent. Google’s true primary competitive threats are product-related sites, especially Amazon. As it gets harder to find a washing machine on Google, people will skip search and go directly to Amazon and other product-related sites.

This is not to say that the links shared on social networks can’t be extremely valuable. But most likely they will be valuable as critical inputs to better search-ranking algorithms. Cody’s point that it’s harder to game humans than machines is very true, but remember that Google’s algorithm was always meant to be based on human-created links. As the spammers have become more sophisticated, the good guys have come to need new mechanisms to determine which links are from trustworthy humans. Social networks might be those new mechanisms, but that doesn’t mean they’ll displace search as the primary method for navigating the web.

Link to original post

You may be interested

5 Effective Strategies for Boosting IoT Security
Internet of Things
79 shares1,127 views
Internet of Things
79 shares1,127 views

5 Effective Strategies for Boosting IoT Security

Ryan Kh - July 25, 2017

With the emergence of IoT devices that are being rolled out from time to time, the serious IoT security issues…

The Future of Healthcare and Big Pharma is in Big Data Analytics
Analytics
418 views
Analytics
418 views

The Future of Healthcare and Big Pharma is in Big Data Analytics

riteshmehta - July 25, 2017

The healthcare industry recognizes that Big Data as and opportunity and a challenge for the whole sector. Nevertheless, systems and…

How Companies Are Rethinking Promotional Materials In Light Of Big Data
Big Data
108 shares1,735 views
Big Data
108 shares1,735 views

How Companies Are Rethinking Promotional Materials In Light Of Big Data

Larry Alton - July 25, 2017

Most people have a pile of promotional items sitting around their homes, from water bottles and t-shirts to calendars and…