By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
SmartData CollectiveSmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
  • Analytics
    AnalyticsShow More
    data-driven white label SEO
    Does Data Mining Really Help with White Label SEO?
    7 Min Read
    marketing analytics for hardware vendors
    IT Hardware Startups Turn to Data Analytics for Market Research
    9 Min Read
    big data and digital signage
    The Power of Big Data and Analytics in Digital Signage
    5 Min Read
    data analytics investing
    Data Analytics Boosts ROI of Investment Trusts
    9 Min Read
    football data collection and analytics
    Unleashing Victory: How Data Collection Is Revolutionizing Football Performance Analysis!
    4 Min Read
  • Big Data
  • BI
  • Exclusive
  • IT
  • Marketing
  • Software
Search
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Are BI Appliances Simply 30 Year Old Databases?
Share
Notification Show More
Aa
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
Aa
Search
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
SmartData Collective > Business Intelligence > Are BI Appliances Simply 30 Year Old Databases?
Business Intelligence

Are BI Appliances Simply 30 Year Old Databases?

sisense
Last updated: 2011/05/04 at 11:53 AM
sisense
9 Min Read
SHARE

In a thought-provoking blog post published by WIT, a business intelligence consulting company in the

In a thought-provoking blog post published by WIT, a business intelligence consulting company in the U.S., the author writes of latest acquisitions relating to Business Intelligence appliances.

BI Appliances

It got me thinking. I’ve been seeing and hearing the term ‘BI appliance’ a lot recently, and whenever I do – I find myself struggling to understand what it means.

More Read

business systems for data driven businesses

Business Management Systems for Data-Driven Businesses

Harnessing the Power of Analytics For Direct-to-Consumer Businesses
The Role of Data Analytics in Football Performance
5 Ways Layered Navigation Improves Business Intelligence Strategies
Embedded BI Tools Bring Huge Benefits to Business Applications

One characteristic that seems to be commonly identified with BI appliances is that they are a combination of software and hardware that form specific functions that have to do with analytics (i.e business intelligence). WIT’s article lists a few examples, including HANA (SAP), HP Business Decision Appliance (Microsoft), Netezza (acquired by IBM) and Greenplum (acquired by EMC).

But is proprietary hardware really required for a so-called BI appliance? No, it’s not. And indeed, I have noticed numerous references to Vertica (acquired by HP) and ElastiCube (by SiSense) as BI appliances. Interestingly enough, both are software-only solutions (i.e. software appliances).

It makes sense, as it shouldn’t matter if your ‘appliance’ runs on proprietary hardware or commodity hardware, if it essentially does that same thing.

The BI Appliance Wars

In a recent interview and in response to quips made by Netezza’s CEO regarding HP’s latest acquisition, Vertica CEO Chris Lynch had this to say about Netezza:

“Their tag line is ‘The power to question everything’. So the first question is: why do they need proprietary hardware? The second question is: why are they using a database engine that’s based on technology from 1982?”

He is obviously angry, but I agree with the premise of his argument. If you’re in the analytics business and you require proprietary hardware – there’s something seriously wrong with your database software technology. Commodity hardware is so powerful today with 64-bit computing and multi-core CPUs, that it’s hard to imagine what type of BI solution would require proprietary hardware.  That is, if your technology was engineered in the 21st century.

The established vendors are not oblivious to this, but rewriting their entire codebase is not something they are willing to do. So some are partnering and/or merging with hardware companies as an alternative. But at some point, scraping this codebase will be unavoidable, or customers will flee due to availability of much better and cheaper alternatives.

BI Appliance or BI Tool?

As if to toss a little more confusion into the mix, the WIT author asks:

“Though I wonder – with memory becoming cheaper and cheaper and with 64 bit platform, why do you have to have a special appliance? Why not use an in-memory tool with tons of RAM ?“

The question itself indicates a misunderstanding of why appliances exist in the first place, and there are a several answers to this question.  Here are a few:

  1. RAM is cheaper, but it’s not cheap. Disk was and always will be cheaper than RAM.
  2. The price of a computer jumps significantly beyond 64GB.  A PC with 64GB of RAM costs significantly less than a server machine with 65GB of RAM, even though there is supposedly just a single GB of memory difference.
  3. In-memory databases assume that the main bottleneck is I/O.  However, when dealing with large amounts of data, this is no longer true.  At such volumes, bottlenecks are between RAM and CPU.

For more information about this, please read In-Memory BI is Not the Future, It’s the Past.

Post originally appeared here

Are BI Appliances Simply 30 Year Old Databases?

In a thought-provoking blog post published by WIT, a business intelligence consulting company in the U.S., the author writes of latest acquisitions relating to Business Intelligence appliances.

BI Appliances

It got me thinking. I’ve been seeing and hearing the term ‘BI appliance’ a lot recently, and whenever I do – I find myself struggling to understand what it means.

One characteristic that seems to be commonly identified with BI appliances is that they are a combination of software and hardware that form specific functions that have to do with analytics (i.e business intelligence). WIT’s article lists a few examples, including HANA (SAP), HP Business Decision Appliance (Microsoft), Netezza (acquired by IBM) and Greenplum (acquired by EMC).

But is proprietary hardware really required for a so-called BI appliance? No, it’s not. And indeed, I have noticed numerous references to Vertica (acquired by HP) and ElastiCube (by SiSense) as BI appliances. Interestingly enough, both are software-only solutions (i.e. software appliances).

It makes sense, as it shouldn’t matter if your ‘appliance’ runs on proprietary hardware or commodity hardware, if it essentially does that same thing.

The BI Appliance Wars

In a recent interview and in response to quips made by Netezza’s CEO regarding HP’s latest acquisition, Vertica CEO Chris Lynch had this to say about Netezza:

“Their tag line is ‘The power to question everything’. So the first question is: why do they need proprietary hardware? The second question is: why are they using a database engine that’s based on technology from 1982?”

He is obviously angry, but I agree with the premise of his argument. If you’re in the analytics business and you require proprietary hardware – there’s something seriously wrong with your database software technology. Commodity hardware is so powerful today with 64-bit computing and multi-core CPUs, that it’s hard to imagine what type of BI solution would require proprietary hardware.  That is, if your technology was engineered in the 21st century.

The established vendors are not oblivious to this, but rewriting their entire codebase is not something they are willing to do. So some are partnering and/or merging with hardware companies as an alternative. But at some point, scraping this codebase will be unavoidable, or customers will flee due to availability of much better and cheaper alternatives.

BI Appliance or BI Tool?

As if to toss a little more confusion into the mix, the WIT author asks:

“Though I wonder – with memory becoming cheaper and cheaper and with 64 bit platform, why do you have to have a special appliance? Why not use an in-memory tool with tons of RAM ?“

The question itself indicates a misunderstanding of why appliances exist in the first place, and there are a several answers to this question.  Here are a few:

  1. RAM is cheaper, but it’s not cheap. Disk was and always will be cheaper than RAM.
  2. The price of a computer jumps significantly beyond 64GB.  A PC with 64GB of RAM costs significantly less than a server machine with 65GB of RAM, even though there is supposedly just a single GB of memory difference.
  3. In-memory databases assume that the main bottleneck is I/O.  However, when dealing with large amounts of data, this is no longer true.  At such volumes, bottlenecks are between RAM and CPU.

For more information about this, please read In-Memory BI is Not the Future, It’s the Past.

TAGGED: business intelligence, hp, microsoft, sap, SiSense, Vertica
sisense May 4, 2011 May 4, 2011
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn
Share

Follow us on Facebook

Latest News

big data and IP laws
Big Data & AI In Collision Course With IP Laws – A Complete Guide
Big Data
ai in marketing
4 Ways AI Can Enhance Your Marketing Strategies
Marketing
sobm for ai-driven cybersecurity
Software Bill of Materials is Crucial for AI-Driven Cybersecurity
Security
IT budgeting for data-driven companies
IT Budgeting Practices for Data-Driven Companies
IT

Stay Connected

1.2k Followers Like
33.7k Followers Follow
222 Followers Pin

You Might also Like

business systems for data driven businesses
Big Data

Business Management Systems for Data-Driven Businesses

9 Min Read
power of analytics
Analytics

Harnessing the Power of Analytics For Direct-to-Consumer Businesses

6 Min Read
football analytics
AnalyticsBig DataExclusive

The Role of Data Analytics in Football Performance

9 Min Read
layered navigation for business intelligence
Business Intelligence

5 Ways Layered Navigation Improves Business Intelligence Strategies

5 Min Read

SmartData Collective is one of the largest & trusted community covering technical content about Big Data, BI, Cloud, Analytics, Artificial Intelligence, IoT & more.

data-driven web design
5 Great Tips for Using Data Analytics for Website UX
Big Data
ai is improving the safety of cars
From Bolts to Bots: How AI Is Fortifying the Automotive Industry
Artificial Intelligence

Quick Link

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Go to mobile version
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?