Cookies help us display personalized product recommendations and ensure you have great shopping experience.

By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
  • Analytics
    AnalyticsShow More
    data analytics and truck accident claims
    How Data Analytics Reduces Truck Accidents and Speeds Up Claims
    7 Min Read
    predictive analytics for interior designers
    Interior Designers Boost Profits with Predictive Analytics
    8 Min Read
    image fx (67)
    Improving LinkedIn Ad Strategies with Data Analytics
    9 Min Read
    big data and remote work
    Data Helps Speech-Language Pathologists Deliver Better Results
    6 Min Read
    data driven insights
    How Data-Driven Insights Are Addressing Gaps in Patient Communication and Equity
    8 Min Read
  • Big Data
  • BI
  • Exclusive
  • IT
  • Marketing
  • Software
Search
© 2008-25 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: More Milk Please, Ermintrude! A Classic Decision Trap?
Share
Notification
Font ResizerAa
SmartData CollectiveSmartData Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • About
  • Help
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-23 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
SmartData Collective > Business Intelligence > More Milk Please, Ermintrude! A Classic Decision Trap?
Business Intelligence

More Milk Please, Ermintrude! A Classic Decision Trap?

Timo Elliott
Timo Elliott
6 Min Read
SHARE

cow-with-name-badge

Contents
Correlation is not CausationCorrelation is not CausationQuick! — Should We Discontinue Bread and Milk?Needed: More Analysis — and Smart PeopleThe Future of Decisions

According to a recent article published in Scientific American, the authors of study assert that:

"Farmers who have named their cows … probably have a better relationship with them. They’re less fearful, more relaxed and less stressed, so that could have an effect on milk yield."

And in a separate article:

"Placing more importance on knowing the individual animals and calling them by name can — at no extra cost to the farmer –— also significantly increase milk production."

Polite farmers and happy cows — who could argue with that?

More Read

ai software is changing the automotive sector
How AI Software is Changing the Future of the Automotive Industry
BI 2010 – Optimizing revenue collection
The Big Data Talent Shortage: Are H1-B Visa Holders the Solution?
Competition is overrated
Mark Hurd on Data, Demographics and Devices

Correlation is not Causation

The article is a cute example of a common problem in BI and decision making: correlation is not the same thing as causation, but people often don’t do enough analysis to know which is which.

I haven’t read the original research on the cows, so I can’t be sure, but there doesn’t seem to be any real evidence for saying there are "no extra costs". The "probably" in the first quote appears to indicate that the stress theory is just a guess, so did the researchers really find a causal effect?, or do both higher milk yields and a propensity for naming …

cow-with-name-badge

According to a recent article published in Scientific American, the authors of study assert that:

"Farmers who have named their cows … probably have a better relationship with them. They’re less fearful, more relaxed and less stressed, so that could have an effect on milk yield."

And in a separate article:

"Placing more importance on knowing the individual animals and calling them by name can — at no extra cost to the farmer –— also significantly increase milk production."

Polite farmers and happy cows — who could argue with that?

Correlation is not Causation

The article is a cute example of a common problem in BI and decision making: correlation is not the same thing as causation, but people often don’t do enough analysis to know which is which.

I haven’t read the original research on the cows, so I can’t be sure, but there doesn’t seem to be any real evidence for saying there are "no extra costs". The "probably" in the first quote appears to indicate that the stress theory is just a guess, so did the researchers really find a causal effect?, or do both higher milk yields and a propensity for naming cows result from something else? Do farmers who name their cows look after them better? Do they spend more money on care?

Without answers to these questions, the information in the study is interesting, but not useful (i.e. would farmers who named their cows — but made no other changes — really get an increase in milk production?)

Quick! — Should We Discontinue Bread and Milk?

It’s very easy to make incorrect decisions with limited analysis. And the problem is sometimes made worse by an emphasis on fast, simplified, "actionable" information for executives.

If you see a chart like this one, showing a supermarket’s profitability by product, for example, you might be tempted to stop selling loss-making bread and milk:

image

But what if it’s a deliberate choice? The analysis misses a crucial point: people don’t buy each product in a supermarket independently of the others. Supermarkets (if they are legally allowed to: not in France) routinely sell some "loss-leader" products such as break, milk, and sugar in order to entice people into their store.

One real-life example of this phenomena, according to IBM:

A large UK supermarket chain sold a low-volume, gourmet cheese that was such a slow mover that the merchandising department considered discontinuing it. But a market-basket analysis of a high-value customer group revealed that the cheese was in many of the largest baskets in this customer group, and dropping the product could have risked disappointing or losing some of its most valuable customers.

(I prefer this apparently real example to the famous "beer and diapers" story, which is more legend than fact)

Needed: More Analysis — and Smart People

In order to make the right decisions using business intelligence, you have to rule out alternate causation effects. But understanding when further analysis might be needed, and what to look at, requires a deep knowledge of the business context — which in turn requires smart people who know what they’re doing.

Any successful business intelligence strategy has to take this into account, and include industry/business/data experts in a business intelligence competency center (BICC).

The Future of Decisions

Still, technology can — and should — help. The decision-making process is under-supported by current business intelligence and performance management tools. One key aspect of "decision intelligence" in the future should be the ability to help people identify when they might be making an over-hasty decision on too-limited data…

________________________________________________

Original cow Image by publicenergy

Share This Article
Facebook Pinterest LinkedIn
Share

Follow us on Facebook

Latest News

data analytics and truck accident claims
How Data Analytics Reduces Truck Accidents and Speeds Up Claims
Analytics Big Data Exclusive
predictive analytics for interior designers
Interior Designers Boost Profits with Predictive Analytics
Analytics Exclusive Predictive Analytics
big data and cybercrime
Stopping Lateral Movement in a Data-Heavy, Edge-First World
Big Data Exclusive
AI and data mining
What the Rise of AI Web Scrapers Means for Data Teams
Artificial Intelligence Big Data Exclusive

Stay Connected

1.2kFollowersLike
33.7kFollowersFollow
222FollowersPin

You Might also Like

Benchmarks Can Reveal the Finance Department’s Achilles Heel

2 Min Read

A Pattern Language for Decision-Making

7 Min Read
business intelligence
AnalyticsBig DataBusiness IntelligenceIT

Business Intelligence: The Importance of Time to Value

5 Min Read

My Regression Theory on Organizational Destruction

6 Min Read

SmartData Collective is one of the largest & trusted community covering technical content about Big Data, BI, Cloud, Analytics, Artificial Intelligence, IoT & more.

ai in ecommerce
Artificial Intelligence for eCommerce: A Closer Look
Artificial Intelligence
data-driven web design
5 Great Tips for Using Data Analytics for Website UX
Big Data

Quick Link

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Follow US
© 2008-25 SmartData Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Go to mobile version
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?